Few societal institutions are as vital yet as overlooked as fatherhood. The moral, economic, and spiritual implications of engaged fatherhood are profound, yet modern policy, legal structures, and cultural narratives often fail to recognize its essential role in human flourishing. Unfortunately, the decline of fatherhood—whether through structural barriers, cultural narratives that marginalize paternal influence, or legal structures that disincentivize engagement—has contributed to many of the social crises we face today: from economic instability to declining educational outcomes and increasing social fragmentation.
The following academic studies each contribute to an emerging body of research that challenges prevailing assumptions about fatherhood, particularly in its legal, theological, and sociological dimensions. June Carbone and Clare Huntington examine how family law and economic structures have weakened paternal influence, leaving many men, especially those without college degrees, alienated from their children. Their study underscores the need for reforms that would encourage father involvement rather than penalize it. Fazel E. Freeks, writing from a theological perspective, explores how faith-based interventions and moral formation can address father absence, gender-based violence, and the erosion of family structures. His work highlights the church’s role in restoring family well-being. Meanwhile, Harmon, James, Young, and Scott provide a compelling counternarrative to deficit-based portrayals of black fatherhood, demonstrating through empirical research that black fathers actively contribute to their children’s educational success despite systemic obstacles.
Together, these studies present a crucial framework for understanding fatherhood as a fundamental pillar of human dignity and social order. They call for a renewed recognition of fathers as indispensable to the formation of stable families and flourishing communities. By engaging these perspectives, we can begin to reclaim a vision of fatherhood that aligns with both classical liberal principles and biblical wisdom—one that affirms the necessity of strong, responsible, and engaged fathers in building a free and virtuous society.
* * *
The article “Fatherhood, Family Law, and the Crisis of Boys and Men,” published in the Columbia Law Review, by June Carbone and Clare Huntington, explores how economic and legal structures have exacerbated the struggles of men, particularly those without college degrees, and how these challenges impact families. The decline in male well-being—manifested in decreasing job opportunities, rising incarceration rates, substance abuse, and mental health struggles—has led to an increase in family instability. This instability particularly affects children, as many fathers, unable to maintain long-term relationships, drift away from their families.
This article highlights the importance of fatherhood in protecting children from poverty. Fathers who are engaged in their children’s lives contribute financially and emotionally, providing stability that reduces childhood disadvantage. Current family law, however, often isolates fathers, especially those who are unmarried or economically insecure. While legal reforms have helped married fathers maintain post-divorce relationships with their children, unmarried fathers are often left without support systems. Child-support laws also punish low-income fathers, enforcing unrealistic financial obligations that can alienate them from their families.
Carbone and Huntington propose legal reforms that would encourage greater father involvement, particularly for men facing economic difficulties. They advocate for community-based centers where fathers and mothers can create parenting agreements outside the adversarial court system. They also recommend changes to child-support enforcement to ensure it encourages, rather than punishes, fatherly involvement. By restructuring family law to support rather than marginalize fathers, society can help men reclaim their roles as both caregivers and providers, ultimately reducing poverty and improving outcomes for children.
* * *
In “Promoting family well-being: A practical and eco-theological engagement,” published in the journal Verbum et Ecclesia, Fazel E. Freeks argues that family well-being is a pillar of a stable and flourishing society, yet it faces significant challenges, particularly in South Africa. Issues such as father absence, gender-based violence (GBV), and moral decline have severely impacted family structures, leading to widespread social instability. Practical theology, particularly eco-theology, offers a holistic framework for addressing these concerns by integrating faith, environmental responsibility, and social ethics. Rooted in the Christian concept of stewardship, eco-theology emphasizes humanity’s duty to care for both creation and the relationships that sustain society.
Father absence remains a critical issue, contributing to emotional distress, behavioral challenges, and socioeconomic hardship. Children without active paternal involvement often struggle with self-esteem, academic performance, and emotional well-being. The absence of fathers affects not only individual households but also entire communities, as it perpetuates cycles of poverty and dysfunction within those communities. Similarly, gender-based violence continues to threaten the dignity and security of women and children, with alarming statistics revealing its prevalence. GBV destabilizes families, weakens social cohesion, and creates an environment of fear and trauma. Alongside these issues, moral decay has become increasingly apparent, affecting the ethical foundation of families and communities. Corruption, crime, and the erosion of traditional values further exacerbate societal fragmentation.
Practical theology provides essential tools for intervention, offering pastoral care and community support to rebuild family structures. Churches and faith-based organizations play a crucial role in equipping families with the moral and spiritual resources needed for resilience and transformation. Recognizing this need, Mosaic Community Developments launched a Family Well-Being Convention, bringing together families from local communities for training and support. This initiative included sessions on fatherhood, GBV, family values, and pastoral counseling. By fostering character development and emphasizing Christian values such as love, respect, and responsibility, the program aimed to restore family stability.
The importance of such faith-based guidance in addressing these social ills was also highlighted by empirical research conducted through structured interviews with 30 families. Participants emphasized the need for stronger family bonds, the reinforcement of Christian values, and greater pastoral involvement in addressing family challenges. Additionally, the study underscored the importance of church attendance in promoting moral development and spiritual growth, particularly among youth.
* * *
A third study, “Black Fathers Rising: A QuantCrit Analysis of Black Fathers’ Paternal Influence on Sons’ Engagement and Sense of School Belonging in High School,” by Willie C. Harmon Jr., Marlon James, Jamaal Young, and Lawrence Scott, in the journal Equity & Excellence in Education, challenges the prevailing narrative that black fathers are disengaged from their children’s education. Using “QuantCrit,” a methodology that merges quantitative analysis with critical race theory, the researchers explore the impact that black fathers have on their sons’ academic engagement and sense of belonging in school.
The authors, all black fathers themselves, were motivated by personal experiences in raising their own children and witnessing the challenges they face in educational settings. Through reflective analysis and empirical research, they highlight how black fathers actively contribute to their sons’ education despite so-called systemic barriers. Rather than accepting deficit-based assumptions that dominate academic discourse, the study reframes black paternal involvement as a form of cultural and educational capital that fosters resilience, critical thinking, and social awareness.
At the core of this research is the concept of black fathers’ “educational habitus,” which builds on Pierre Bourdieu’s notion of habitus—the social and cultural conditioning that shapes individuals’ behavior and expectations. The study refines this theory by identifying four key ways that black fathers cultivate success in their sons: (1) managing responsibility, which includes instilling academic discipline and self-motivation; (2) strategizing, or teaching sons to navigate systemic barriers; (3) developing analytical skills, helping sons become independent problem solvers; and (4) promoting moral values and encouraging a lifelong commitment to justice.
The authors argue that mainstream research frequently overlooks the experiential knowledge of black fathers, leading to misleading conclusions about paternal disengagement. By incorporating parenting experiences into the analysis, the study challenges stereotypical assumptions about black fathers and presents a more accurate and affirming narrative of black fatherhood.
Ultimately, the research calls for a shift in how black paternal involvement is studied and discussed. It advocates for future research to move beyond deficit frameworks and instead recognize black fathers as active, engaged, and critical influences in their children’s educational success. By recentering the discussion on strengths rather than shortcomings, the study contributes to a more nuanced understanding of black fatherhood and its impact on youth development.
In sum, the research presented in these articles underscores a fundamental truth: Engaged fathers are essential for education success, lifting children out of poverty, and cultivating the moral virtues necessary for personal well-being and community flourishing. Whether through economic support, moral instruction, or emotional guidance, fathers provide stability and structure that no government program or social initiative can replicate. The breakdown of fatherhood—whether due to legal barriers, economic instability, or cultural marginalization—has left countless children vulnerable to cycles of poverty, educational failure, and social dysfunction. Yet, as these studies demonstrate, the presence of a committed father significantly improves a child’s ability to navigate life’s challenges with resilience and purpose.
Rebuilding the role of fathers in the family is not simply a social policy concern—it is a moral imperative. Strong, virtuous fathers create strong, virtuous children, and in turn, strong, virtuous communities. If society is to address the root causes of poverty, crime, and cultural decline, it must begin with restoring and affirming the indispensable role of fathers in the lives of their children.
